Este es el blog de, por y para los alumnos de los grupos 223 y 226 de la asignatura de Economía del Comportamiento que imparte el Departamento de Teoría Económica de la Facultad de Ciencias Económicas de la UAM
martes, 31 de enero de 2012
La economía de la selección de pareja en el matrimonio
¿Puede la economía decir algo sobre ese paradigmático comportamiento si no irracional sí, al menos, extra-racional que es la elección de pareja para el matrimonio?
Leed lo que dice al respecto Robert Frank refiriéndose fundamentalmente al comportamiento de los chinos.
Supply, Demand and
Marriage
By ROBERT H. FRANK
IN some cultures, romance isn’t nearly as important as cash
when it comes to choosing a marriage partner. And even
when money plays no explicit role in selecting a mate,
courtship customs are governed by the venerable economic
model of supply and demand.
Under the dowry system in India, for example, parents of
older brides would typically pay more to prospective grooms.
Men with better jobs would receive larger payments, too.
2
In short, there really is a marriage market in many countries
around the world, and economic principles apply to it. In
markets with a preponderance of women seeking partners,
the terms of trade shift in favor of men. If more men are
seeking partners, the reverse is true. Two cases in point are
the baby-boom generation in the United States and the
current youth cohort in China.
In the United States, the end of World War II and the return
of millions of troops set off the baby boom. In the second half
of the 1940s, the population swelled by almost 14 percent,
versus growth of less than half of 1 percent during the first
half of the decade. By the mid-1960s, many of those babies
were reaching the traditional marriage age.
At the time, it was American custom for women to marry
men several years older than themselves. In a typical
wedding in 1969, for example, the bride might have been
born in 1947 and the groom in 1943. Because of that custom,
women at the leading edge of the baby boom confronted a
significant shortfall of potential marriage partners.
Economics teaches us that when there is excess demand for a
good, its price rises. According to this model, excess demand
for grooms should have caused the terms of courtship to shift
in favor of men.
Before the 1960s, cultural norms encouraged celibacy before
3
marriage. The breakdown of those norms has been widely
attributed to the introduction of oral contraception, which
gave women an unintrusive way to protect themselves
against an unwanted pregnancy. The pill no doubt played a
role — perhaps a very big one — but skeptics object that
effective alternative forms of contraception had long since
been available.
The supply-and-demand model bolsters the skeptics’
concerns. Biologists describe a fundamental asymmetry in
the sexual strategies favored by males and females in
vertebrate species. Males, whose sex cells are cheap to
produce, tend to favor more transient sexual relationships,
whereas females, for whom pregnancy and birth are far more
costly, tend to favor greater commitment. The sexual
revolution, which bent cultural norms toward male
preferences, may thus be partly explained by the excess
demand for grooms in the 1960s.
An imbalance in the opposite direction characterizes the
contemporary marriage market in China. The Chinese
government’s one-child policy, combined with a cultural
preference for sons and technologies that permit selective
abortion, have helped to create a large sex-ratio imbalance
among young Chinese. For every 100 women in that group,
there are now more than 120 men.
According to market models, the terms of trade in the
4
Chinese marriage market should have shifted sharply in
favor of women. And evidence suggests that young Chinese
women and their families have in fact become much more
selective in recent years.
They appear, for example, to focus more critically on the
earnings potential of prospective mates. Because house size
is often assumed to be a reliable signal of wealth, a family
can enhance its son’s marriage prospects by spending a
larger fraction of its income on housing. (Other families can
follow the same strategy, of course, but when all families do
so, the resulting homes are still reliable indicators of relative
wealth.) Such a shift appears to have occurred.
For example, when Shang-Jin Wei, an economist at
Columbia University, and Xiaobo Zhang of the International
Food Policy Research Institute examined the size
distribution of Chinese homes, they found that families with
sons built houses that were significantly larger than those
built by families with daughters, even after controlling for
family income and other factors. They also generally found
that the higher a city’s male-to-female ratio, the bigger the
average house size of families that have sons.
Mr. Wei reports that many families with sons have begun to
add a phantom third story to their homes, one that looks
normal from the outside but whose interior space remains
completely unfinished.
5
“Marriage brokers are familiar with the tactic,” he reports,
“yet many refuse to schedule meetings with a family’s son
unless the family house has three stories.”
Risk-taking among men is another marker of the terms of
trade in marriage markets. Biologists have long argued that
men’s relative willingness to engage in risk is an evolutionary
legacy of polygynous mating systems, those in which males
with the most resources took more than one mate. That
means males with the least resources were left with none —
the worst thing that could happen in Darwinian terms.
Fast-forward to humans today, and we can see why men may
view financial risk-taking as a compelling strategy. Let’s say a
man who is single has a chance to invest his last $10,000 in a
very risky business venture. If it succeeds, he gets $1 million
and is much more successful socially in finding mates.
So even if the odds of success are small, it would be rational
— in Darwinian terms — for him to make the investment,
because he would fail for sure if he doesn’t.
How is this showing up in China? Mr. Wei and Mr. Zhang
find evidence that men are more likely to make risky
financial investments in cities with higher male-to-female
ratios. Their specific finding was that significantly more local
businesses are started in such cities. This doesn’t appear
attributable to other factors, since cities’ sex ratios seem to
6
have no effect on the number of businesses started by
foreigners.
The choice of a marriage partner is one of the most
important decisions in life. It’s clearly very different from
choosing a car. Yet in many ways, it appears to obey a
strikingly similar market logic.
Robert H. Frank is an economics professor at the Johnson
Graduate School of Management at Cornell University
domingo, 29 de enero de 2012
Temas trabajos de investigación
Aquí va la lista de temas de investigación propuestos. No es excluyente, de modo que si algún grupo tinen algún tema que le interese investigar, puede proponérnoslo.
Ya sabéis los pasos: constituid los grupos, enviárnoslos por e-mail junto con el trabajo elegido, y esperad a que recibáis nuestra confirmación.
Ya sabéis los pasos: constituid los grupos, enviárnoslos por e-mail junto con el trabajo elegido, y esperad a que recibáis nuestra confirmación.
TEMAS DE TRABAJOS DE INVESTIGACIÓN
I)
EL
CLIMA Y EL COMPORTAMIENTO ECONÓMICO.
La cuestión a plantearse es la de si la situación
geográfica, independientemente de cualesquiera otras consideraciones, afecta al
comportamiento económico y a las perspectivas de crecimiento.
II)
RELIGIÓN Y COMPORTAMIENTO
ECONÓMICO I: ISLAM Y MUNDO JUDEOCRISTIANO.
La cuestión aquí a tratar es la de si las características
distintivas entre la civilización judeocristiana y la musulmana se traducen en
comportamientos económicos diferenciales acerca de la actitud al trabajo, el ahorro, la innovación y la desigualdad.
III)
RELIGIÓN Y COMPORTAMIENTO
ECONÓMICO II: CATOLICISMO Y PROTESTANTISMO.
El objetivo de este tema es analizar la pertinencia de la
tesis de Max Weber en siu obra La ética protestante y el espíritu del
capitalismo respecto a la diferencia de comportamiento económico entre
protestantes/calvinistas y católicos
IV)
CULTURA Y COMPORTAMIENTO ECONÓMICO: ORIENTE
versus OCCIDENTE.
¿Es el comportamiento económico de los ciudadanos de los
países del Lejano Oriente diferente al de los países occidentales en cuestiones
como la actitud al trabajo, el ahorro, la innovación o el respeto a las normas?
V)
GÉNERO Y COMPORTAMIENTO ECONÓMICO.
¿Responden de modo similar los hombres y mujeres ante los incentivos y
oportunidades económicas?
VI)
PSICOLOGÍA Y CRISIS ECONÓMICA.
Junto con las tradicionales explicaciones de la actual crisis económica, desde la psicología se ha avanzado una explicación en función del tipo de comportamiento de los operadores en los mercados financieros.
Junto con las tradicionales explicaciones de la actual crisis económica, desde la psicología se ha avanzado una explicación en función del tipo de comportamiento de los operadores en los mercados financieros.
jueves, 26 de enero de 2012
Sobre la clasificación económica de las actividades
Sobre las actividades productivas, improductivas y destructivas, la referencia clave es el artículo de William Baumol que se encuentra en inglés en este sitio:
http://business2.fiu.edu/1660397/www/Definitions%20of%20Entrepreneurship/Baumol_1990.pdf.
En castellano, aparece traducido como un capítulo en su libro Mercados Perfectos y virtud natural .
Se trata de un texto realmente magnífico repleto de intuiciones acerca de los empresarios y los emprendedores en distintas circunstancias históricas. Es de lectura amena. En suma, que es altamente aconsejable.
http://business2.fiu.edu/1660397/www/Definitions%20of%20Entrepreneurship/Baumol_1990.pdf.
En castellano, aparece traducido como un capítulo en su libro Mercados Perfectos y virtud natural .
Se trata de un texto realmente magnífico repleto de intuiciones acerca de los empresarios y los emprendedores en distintas circunstancias históricas. Es de lectura amena. En suma, que es altamente aconsejable.
miércoles, 25 de enero de 2012
Para empezar
Un sitio al que os tenéis que subscribir obligadamente es el de TED. En el podéis ver y escuchar en charlas de unos 15-20 minutos a científicos, literatos, políticos, economistas, sociólogos, historiadores, etc., etc, de primera fila hablando sobre los temas más variopintos ofreciendo los puntos de vista más avanzados sobre ellos. Fijaos en que casi todos están subtitulados, así que los que todavía no seáis capaces de seguirlos en inglés, no tienen excusa.
Y, para empezar, aquí os dejo colgados los links a dos de ellos de relevancia para nuestra asignatura:
http://www.ted.com/talks/laurie_santos.html;
http://www.ted.com/talks/dan_ariely_asks_are_we_in_control_of_our_own_decisions.html
Observad que el segundo, es la intervención de Dan Ariely, que es uno de los autores recomendados para seguir este curso.
Ya estáis perdiendo el tiempo si no los estáis viendo.
Y, para empezar, aquí os dejo colgados los links a dos de ellos de relevancia para nuestra asignatura:
http://www.ted.com/talks/laurie_santos.html;
http://www.ted.com/talks/dan_ariely_asks_are_we_in_control_of_our_own_decisions.html
Observad que el segundo, es la intervención de Dan Ariely, que es uno de los autores recomendados para seguir este curso.
Ya estáis perdiendo el tiempo si no los estáis viendo.
Suscribirse a:
Entradas (Atom)